The 3 Elements of Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
What is the Impact of TCO on Your Business
TCO
is a technique used by businesses to measure the cost of their
assets, including the expenses for their operation in addition to
the price paid for their acquisition.
It is important to note
that while TCO may sound like an accounting
term, it is used neither in the recording or reporting of
transactions. Instead, its purpose is for the evaluation of
potential purchases (often referred to as “projects”) by the
decision makers.
Total Cost is
Not the Same as Price
All
too frequently, business owners mistake total cost of ownership with
price. However, TCO should be a method of drawing attention to the
difference between price and what the project’s costs will be over
the long term. Price is only a single part of the analysis performed
for TCO calculations.
Once you understand the
difference between price and cost of ownership, you will be able to
utilize this important tool for important calculations regarding several kinds
of purchase and investment decisions such as: buildings, IT infrastructure,
manufacturing equipment, and vehicles.
By making a total cost of
ownership analysis a part of your decision making process for
purchases and acquisitions, you may be better prepared to have a
more accurate view of the value of that decision. It can have an
impact on everything from your capital acquisition prioritization,
to vendor selection and even your budgeting process.
The 3 Primary Elements of
Total Cost of Ownership
The three main elements of
a calculation of TCO are:
·
Costs of Acquisitions
– This part of the calculation has to do
with the cost of property or equipment after discounts, commissions,
closing fees, and purchasing incentives, but before taxes.
Occasionally, this will involve the single acquisition of upgrades
or peripheral products required for the installation or use of the
purchase.
·
Costs of Operation
– This factor includes the services
and subscriptions that are required in order to be able to use the
acquisitions that have been purchased. This may include direct
operator labor, initial training, maintenance materials, equipment
and services, and utility costs.
·
Cost of Personnel
– This portion of ownership cost involves the overhead to
cover personnel, which can include those involved in the operation
of the acquisition, the support staff for the asset, facility
housing personnel, and the administrative team. It may also include
ongoing training personnel and labor for the maintenance and
troubleshooting of the asset.
Contributions of
Accounting to Total Cost of Ownership Calculations
The actual cost won’t be accurate if it involves only the expenses, but
must also include the incremental revenue flows or savings that are
associated by owning and operating with this asset.
The TCO is mitigated by the “business status quo” versus the
changes to the cash flow. That amount is calculated by use of Net
Present Value calculations in order to analyze the value over the
long term.
The Drawbacks of Using
Total Cost of Ownership
There are a number of
drawbacks with this process and its use
for making decisions. While it can be a good guide, because of the
following factors, it should not be the singular decision-making
consideration. These factors are as follows:
·
does not include the risk or time value of money into account
·
TCO also doesn’t consider the option value within systems that are
more flexible
·
It is very rare to be able to accurate perform a general comparison
of two systems independent of circumstances
·
The quantity of difficult to forecast numbers makes data fundamentally unreliable
Due to these drawbacks,
TCO analysis is intrinsically flawed. It does
take some time, the compilation of many solid numbers, research, and
a good understanding of the investment or acquisition as a whole in
order to allow it to gauge the potential impact that it may have on
the business.
That
said, when used correctly and not exclusively, calculations using
these methods can be highly beneficial as a part of a complete
toolbox for decision making for a company of any size.